By Dr. Jennifer Jeschke
An employee approaches their supervisor and says, "My shoulder has been bothering me." They're still working. There's no obvious emergency. But the discomfort isn't going away. What happens next?
Does the supervisor contact HR? Should the employee see a medical provider? Is first aid appropriate? What if the employee can still perform their job but their symptoms are getting worse?
For employers, the first response to an employee reporting pain or discomfort can influence what happens next. Without a clear process, employees may delay seeking help, supervisors may be unsure how to respond, and minor concerns may go unaddressed.
Workplace Injury Response Process
Having an established workplace injury response process helps employers recognize concerns, determine appropriate next steps, and connect employees with the right resources.
1. Start With the Employee's Report
Consider an employee who performs repetitive overhead work. They've noticed increasing shoulder discomfort but are still able to complete their regular duties.
There was no specific accident, and the employee doesn't consider the problem serious enough to seek immediate medical attention. Before deciding what to do, employers need to understand the situation.
Important questions include:
- When did the discomfort begin?
- Did something specific happen, or did symptoms develop gradually?
- What activities or job tasks make the discomfort worse?
- Has the employee noticed changes in strength, movement, or ability to perform their job?
- Are symptoms improving, staying the same, or getting worse?
The supervisor's role is to recognize the concern, follow the organization's reporting procedures, and connect the employee with an appropriate resource, not to diagnose the condition. The goal is to make sure the employee's concern doesn't get overlooked simply because they can still work.
2. Know Who Makes the First Assessment
When an employee reports pain at work, the next step should be clear. Depending on the organization, the initial contact may be a supervisor, safety professional, HR representative, designated first aid responder, or occupational health provider.
However, reporting a concern and evaluating it are two different responsibilities.
A supervisor may recognize that an employee is having difficulty with a task, but they may not have the clinical training to determine whether the concern requires first aid, further assessment, or medical attention.
An established response process should identify:
- Who receives and documents the initial report
- Who is qualified to assess the employee's symptoms and function
- What first aid resources are available
- When an outside medical provider should be contacted
- Who coordinates follow up and additional care
For employers without an onsite medical resource, access to an on-site occupational physical therapist or other qualified healthcare provider can help fill this gap. Depending on the employer's needs, this may include onsite services or access to a nearby clinic.
3. Not Every Complaint Requires the Same Response
One of the most important parts of workplace injury management is recognizing that not every report of discomfort should follow the same path. A qualified healthcare provider can help determine whether symptoms are appropriate for first aid and monitoring or require additional medical evaluation.
A useful framework is to consider three general levels of concern.
Green Light: Manage and Monitor
Some employees report mild discomfort without significant changes in movement or function.
When an appropriate assessment identifies no concerning findings, the next steps may include:
- Appropriate first aid measures
- Education about safe work practices
- Monitoring symptoms and functional changes
- Establishing a clear follow up plan
Even when symptoms appear minor, employers should have a process for reassessment if the concern continues.
Yellow Light: Assess and Reassess
Other situations require a closer look.
Examples include:
- Symptoms that persist or repeatedly return
- Changes in strength, movement, or work performance
- Discomfort associated with repetitive or physically demanding tasks
- Limited improvement following initial intervention
These situations may benefit from a more detailed musculoskeletal evaluation that considers both the employee's condition and their job responsibilities.
Red Light: Escalate
Certain symptoms or circumstances warrant prompt medical attention.
Examples may include:
- Severe or rapidly worsening symptoms
- Significant swelling or obvious deformity
- New numbness, weakness, or loss of movement
- A significant injury mechanism
- Symptoms that suggest a more serious medical condition
Emergency symptoms require immediate emergency care.
This framework helps organize an employer's response but does not replace an evaluation by a qualified healthcare professional. Employees should receive prompt medical attention whenever symptoms or circumstances warrant it.
4. Look Beyond the Pain: Consider the Job Demands
An employee's shoulder pain may be the immediate concern, but understanding the physical demands of their job can provide valuable context. For example, an employee who repeatedly reaches overhead may experience different physical stresses than someone who spends most of the day at a desk.
A work focused assessment may consider:
- Force: How much physical effort does the task require?
- Frequency: How often is the movement repeated?
- Duration: How long does the employee perform the activity?
- Posture: Does the task involve awkward positions or extended reaching?
- Equipment: Could the workstation, tools, or equipment contribute to physical strain?
- Movement: How does the employee perform the task?
This information helps identify possible contributing factors and opportunities to improve how work is performed. In some cases, recommendations may involve adjusting equipment, changing task sequences, improving body mechanics, or incorporating appropriate movement breaks.
Understanding the job is an important part of understanding the employee's functional needs.
5. Document the Concern and the Response
Documentation is an essential part of an effective workplace injury response process. It helps employers track concerns, communicate with appropriate providers, and understand what actions were taken.
Depending on the circumstances and applicable policies, documentation should address:
- Employee report: What symptoms or concerns did the employee describe?
- Timing: When did the symptoms begin, and when were they reported?
- Work activities: What tasks or movements may be contributing?
- Functional status: Is the employee experiencing difficulty performing specific duties?
- Intervention: What first aid or other actions were provided, and by whom?
- Employee response: Did symptoms improve, remain unchanged, or worsen?
- Follow up: When will the concern be reassessed, and who is responsible?
- Escalation: Was additional medical evaluation recommended or obtained?
Employers should also distinguish between workplace recommendations and formal medical restrictions, including who has the authority to establish them. Accurate documentation supports continuity of care and appropriate workplace decision making.
What About OSHA Recordkeeping?
Not every report of pain or discomfort automatically becomes an OSHA recordable injury. Recordability depends on the circumstances, including whether the condition is work related and whether it meets OSHA's recording criteria.
OSHA distinguishes between first aid and medical treatment beyond first aid. Certain interventions, such as hot or cold therapy, nonrigid supports, and massage, are included in OSHA's first aid definition.
However, physical therapy and therapeutic exercises used to treat a specific work related injury are generally considered medical treatment beyond first aid. Other circumstances, including qualifying work restrictions or days away from work, may also make a work related case recordable.
Employers should follow applicable OSHA recordkeeping requirements and their established reporting procedures. The objective is appropriate employee care and accurate documentation, not avoiding a recordable injury.
6. Establish a Clear Follow Up and Escalation Plan
An initial assessment is only one part of the process. What happens if the employee reports the same discomfort several days later? What if their ability to perform a task changes? What if first aid hasn't helped?
Without a follow up process, these concerns can be missed. A workplace injury response plan should establish:
- When the employee will be reassessed
- Who is responsible for following up
- What changes should trigger additional evaluation
- How recommendations will be communicated
- When the employee should be referred for further medical care
If symptoms persist, worsen, or affect the employee's ability to work safely, the response should be reconsidered rather than continuing an ineffective approach. The goal is to make informed decisions based on how the employee is responding.
7. Use Employee Reports to Identify Workplace Risks
An employee's report of discomfort can also provide useful information about workplace conditions. For example, if several employees performing the same task report shoulder discomfort, the concern may extend beyond an individual employee.
Employers can look for patterns involving:
- Repetitive movements
- Heavy or frequent lifting
- Awkward working postures
- Specific workstations or equipment
- Particular departments, shifts, or job tasks
These patterns may help identify opportunities for ergonomic improvements, employee education, equipment changes, or additional injury prevention measures. Rather than treating each report as an isolated concern, employers can use the information to strengthen their overall workplace safety efforts.
Does Your Organization Have a Clear Workplace Injury Response Plan?
Consider how your organization would respond if an employee reported increasing back or shoulder discomfort tomorrow.
Ask yourself:
- Does the employee know who to tell? Is there a clear and accessible reporting process?
- Who evaluates the concern? Is a qualified resource available to assess symptoms and functional limitations?
- Are job demands considered? Does the assessment account for the physical activities the employee performs?
- What gets documented? Is there a consistent process for recording concerns, interventions, and employee responses?
- What happens next? Is there a defined follow up and escalation process if symptoms don't improve?
If the answers aren't clear, your organization may have gaps worth addressing.
Having a reliable response process helps employees receive appropriate attention while giving employers greater confidence in their injury management decisions.
Strengthen Your Workplace Injury Response With Optimal Physical Therapy
When an employee reports pain or discomfort, employers shouldn't have to guess what happens next.
An established response process and access to qualified occupational health resources can help organizations evaluate concerns, consider job demands, document interventions, and determine when additional care is needed.
Optimal Physical Therapy works with employers in Lake Mills, WI, and surrounding communities to support workplace injury prevention and employee health.
Our employer services include early intervention, onsite physical therapy clinics, ergonomic risk assessments, job demand analysis, OSHA first aid training, and other occupational health solutions.
Does your organization have a clear plan for responding when an employee reports discomfort?
Contact Optimal Physical Therapy or call 920-648-2400 to learn how we can help your organization strengthen its workplace injury response process.

